Downtown St. Augustine, Florida

Come take a look at our extensive collection of fossils, minerals, artifacts, meteorites, & much, much more!

127 St George St, St. Augustine, FL 32084 · ★ Read our reviews on Yelp

The Shop

Millions of years,
one small storefront.

From fossils older than history itself, crystal and mineral specimens found all around the world, meteorites from the great beyond, and unique historical artifacts, we have a little something for everyone!

Stop in, ask questions, and stay curious 🦖

Fossils Minerals Artifacts Meteorites

This place started as a retirement project and is the result of a lifelong passion that got its own storefront in 2020, right in the heart of downtown St. Augustine!

The Case

Currently in the case

We offer a wide variety of specimens at different price points, and we offer even more at our physical location!

Prices reflect the last time this page was updated.

Want a heads-up before rare pieces hit the case?

We'll only use this to announce new arrivals via our mailing list.

Visit

Find us on
St. George Street

Prehistoric is a fossil, mineral, artifact and meteorite shop at 127 St George St, in the historic district of downtown St. Augustine, Florida.

Get Directions
Locality 127 St George St
St. Augustine, FL 32084
Hours Daily 11am–6pm
Sat until 7pm Checking hours…

Hours can shift around holidays. Please feel free to give us a quick call to check our hours if you're planning on making a special trip.

We are also close to many of the other locations in Saint Augustine worth visiting! Castillo de San Marcos, the Lightner Museum, and the Pirate & Treasure Museum are all an easy walk, so it's simple to squeeze in a quick stop by our shop!

Think you found a meteorite?

Unfortunately, not everything heavy and strange looking that turns up in your yard is one! Here's a good field guide on finding out if it really is one before you bring it in.

Meteorite or meteorwrong →

Word on the Street

Don't just take our word for it!

Feel free to read about the many positive experiences customers have had visiting us throughout the years! Been in already? We'd love to hear how it went.

Fantastic find in St. Augustine! Really cool store with tons of teeth and arrowheads and coins, I got a piece of meteorite on a necklace and it's beautiful. Friendly wonderful staff!

Shelly P.

You don't have to be Indy to appreciate the history in this shop. From fascinating fossils to magnificent Maglidon teeth, this shop has a little of everything.

Josh S.

Prehistoric St. Augustine was one of the most surprising and unique shops I found during my visit to St. Augustine.

Osvaldo V., translated from Spanish

A beautiful shop. The displays are well kept and very well labeled. It was a joy to look through all that the store had to offer.

Lily K.

I was blown away by the amazing natural wonders inside! … The owner had an incredible wealth of knowledge and was very friendly and informative.

Stephen B.

Super neat store! Lots of things to look at with cool history. Take home a geode, crystal, even a shark or dinosaur tooth!

Ariana G.

The prices are a bit high, but the place is really cool.

Hector R., translated from Spanish

This place is so interesting and unique. One of a kind - and the owner is very friendly 👍 don't miss it if you have kids (or even if you don't)!

Melissa L.

My husband and I really enjoyed visiting this store. I bought a pretty heart rock and my husband bought a megaladon sharks tooth. They are so cool! … We loved it!

Kelly W.

A must-visit shop; you won't be able to leave without taking home a piece of Jurassic history. The staff are lovely.

Atamnia H., translated from French

FAQ

Before you stop in

Where is Prehistoric in St. Augustine?

We're at 127 St George St, in the historic district of downtown St. Augustine. See the map and directions.

What are your hours?

We're open daily from 11am to 6pm, and until 7pm on Saturdays. Hours can shift around holidays, so if you're making a special trip, give us a call at (904) 770-7869.

What kinds of things do you sell?

We sell fossils, crystal and mineral specimens from around the world, meteorites, and unique historical artifacts. Every piece is one of a kind, so the shelves are always changing. What we offer online is only a fraction of what we have available at our physical location, so it is always worth visiting us in person if you want more variety! See what's in the case right now.

Do you ship?

Yes. Not local? Just mention it when you ask about a piece and we'll work out shipping with you. Send us a message.

Can I return a piece?

Yes. You have 90 days from purchase (or from delivery, if we shipped it) to return a piece for a full refund. It just needs to come back in the same condition, with your receipt or other proof of purchase. Bring it by the shop, or mail it back to us; you cover the return postage. If you're mailing it, let us know so we can watch for it. Separately, our authenticity guarantee never runs out: if a piece ever turns out not to be what we said it was, bring or send it back and we'll refund it in full.

Can I buy pieces from the online case?

The online case is a look at what's on the shelves right now. Save the pieces you like with the heart, then use the inquiry buttons to message us. Everything is one of a kind and is on a first-come, first-served basis, so we'll let you know if a piece is still here.

How do I know the item I am purchasing is authentic?

We will, upon request, email you within 2-3 business days a certificate of authenticity in PDF form. It is always recommended that buyers purchase fossils from sellers who offer unconditional lifetime guarantees of authenticity, and who otherwise stand behind their sales (as does Prehistoric).

Get In Touch

Ask us anything

Can't make it to the shop today? Send a note! We are more than happy to answer questions about a piece, fulfill shipping requests, or just talk rocks!

We'll only use this to get back to you and will not spam you with unnecessary information!